Three simple questions you should ask to determine if your patents are worth it.
The US Patent Office recently reported that 97 percent of patents never make any money for the inventor. The Federal Trade Commission cited an even lower rate of success: less than 1 percent.
It seems inconceivable that any business would hand over large amounts of cash for an asset that has less than a 3 percent chance of generating a return (you’re better off at the Roulette table, with those odds) but regardless, they do.
This doesn’t mean patents are ‘bad’. Patents can, in fact, be incredibly valuable. Unfortunately they can also be a total waste of time and money. What is remarkable however is how often we come across companies that spend substantial amounts on patents but have never stopped to check what their return on this spend really is.
When faced with this situation, we ask the patent owner three simple questions:
1. Have you licensed these patents to anyone?
2. Have you litigated (enforced) these patents against anyone?
3. Do you have an active program to sell these patents to a third party and are they interested in buying?
Over the long term, if the answer to these three questions is no there’s absolutely no point in having a patent. Why?
The answer lies in the nature of patents: a patent is sword, not a shield – you need to actively use it to generate value. You can extract that value in three fundamental ways.
First, by convincing a third party to pay you to use your patented technology. This could be a one-off fee, an ongoing royalty, a premium on the product relative to competitor products or even a commitment to buy the product. You could also ask them to stop using your technology all together to secure market share.
Second, if asking politely doesn’t cause them to cough up money or do what you want, you either walk away or sue and recover sufficient damages or other advantages (injunctions, suit dismissals) to offset what are likely to be substantial litigation costs. In New Zealand these are about $250K for a high court trial, in the US they start at approximately $1.5 million. Large bets on long odds, indeed.
Third, recent years have seen the emergence of patent markets so you can try to sell your patent. The value of your patent is essentially a function of (1) and (2). That is, if it’s not capable of generating income or being a useful weapon in a patent litigation suit then its effective value is likely to be very low or zero.
So if you’re not doing one or more of the above (if you’re not wielding the sword or selling it someone who can) there is no point in having a patent at all. Put simply: patents sitting on the shelf have zero value, regardless of what you paid for them or what your patent attorney tells you they’re worth. It also pays to note that patents are perishable; they have a finite life and every week their potential value ebbs away. Just like a sword, eventually they rust away.
I learnt this lesson from a former boss who completed the largest patent sale in history. He took over as general counsel at a major US corporation that had hundreds of patents it never enforced and was paying millions of dollars in fees for.
The first thing he did was start an aggressive license campaign followed by suing anyone who didn’t co-operate. Long story short: he turned a department costing millions into one generating millions. He was prepared to wield the sword.
So if you have patents and you’re not actively licensing, litigating or selling them you need to ask some long, hard questions about your IP strategy. As always it pays to ask those questions to someone other than the person who filed your patents or who will litigate them.
Paul Adams is CEO of EverEdge IP, one of the world’s leading intangible asset and technology commercialisation firms. Paul has been named one of the world’s top IP strategists and was the recipient of the Outstanding IP Leader Award 2012. www.everedgeip.com.
Idealog has been covering the most interesting people, businesses and issues from the fields of innovation, design, technology and urban development for over 12 years. And we're asking for your support so we can keep telling those stories, inspire more entrepreneurs to start their own businesses and keep pushing New Zealand forward. Give over $5 a month and you will not only be supporting New Zealand innovation, but you’ll also receive a print subscription and a copy of the new book by David Downs and Dr. Michelle Dickinson, No. 8 Recharged (while stocks last).
Idealog is part of ICG. We work with clients like Woolworths New Zealand, All Good, Huffer, Liquorland, Resene, Citta Design, TVNZ, Spark and FCB on their event activations, in-store, in-office or out-of-home signage, content creation and vehicle wraps.