Ramming it home: after a traditional Chinese building wins a major architectural award, what can New Zealand learn?
The socialist-thinking surfer who built his first rammed earth home in Raglan has dedicated over 25 years to a trade specialty that was almost unheard of in 1980s Aotearoa. With influences from around the world, Geraets is confident there’s a compelling and meaningful story to tell, so, just three months before the Guangming Village took the win at the World Architectural Festival in Berlin, he commissioned a book to chronicle rammed earth in New Zealand.
These homes are known for thick, natural looking walls that reveal pleasing textural imperfection. They can be found in the form of cool, multi-million-dollar oases in Californian desert spaces to centuries old Asian and middle-eastern villages and cities. Typically, Westerners who’ve commissioned these homes have been green-leaning early adopters or simply rich folk who want something few others have.
Pompallier House, Russell. Possibly New Zealand’s first rammed earth structure.
But, as Geraets says, attitudes to the craft that blends hundreds of years of wisdom with modern requests for sustainability and energy efficiency are changing.
“At the last three home shows we’ve definitely been getting more enquiries from a diverse range of people. Not surprisingly, they’re looking for natural feeling, sustainable ‘behaving’ options when they approach my stand. What they learn if they’re prepared to go down the RE path is that the ‘sustainable building’ claims come not only from reduced carbon footprints due to more local material sourcing, but also for the longevity of the building. It was actually this long-lasting, generational feature that contributed to the award decision for juries at the World Architecture Festival in Berlin.”
Rammed earth differs from other forms of earth housing in that a mixture of soil, a clay/ sand mix, and these days, a 10% measure of strength-ensuring cement is vertically rammed either by hand or pneumatically. The wall is created in position on site, by pouring the earth mix into casings or forms, which are removed after ‘ramming’ is finished.
As the forms are removed the walls stand robust and complete; it’s sometimes referred to as a kind of man-made, vastly accelerated sedimentary rock.
Leading architectural commentators, Design Boom, stressed the decision was about “ordinary people” in Guangming village: ‘The project reinvented the traditional building technology, providing villagers with a safe, economical, comfortable and sustainable reconstruction strategy that they could afford, own, and pass on to their children.’
Geraets reiterates that the award “is significant due to the promise it puts forward to place the (architectural) needs of the community over the golden fleece of developers’ profit margins, construction supply industries and banks.”
We might be celebrating now, but rammed earth hasn’t been a particularly popular concept in the western world. In the 1930s, South Dakota University began a rammed earth project that is still fully functional today. Despite its success, earth building writer Sim Van Der Ryn explains in Alternative Construction that the career of the man who initiated it was doomed, because of the unorthodox nature of the project at the time: ‘Anyone contemplating natural building materials would have been drummed out of the design and buildings profession.’
Fast forward to now and builders like Geraets now work to industry building codes, specially tailored to earth constructions in the last 15 years. New Zealand has developed internationally applauded codes for RE, but the heating/cooling aspect of these structures still lacks Kiwi recognition for its thermal benefits.
“The building industry here still holds standard wall insulation as the holy grail of thermal performance,” says Geraets, who has discussed this matter with his engineer, Doctor Paul Jaquin.
The ex-pat Brit did his PhD in RE construction and is an international expert and speaker on the subject. Dr Jaquin is also a member of the panel updating New Zealand’s earth building design codes. Geraets hopes the WBY award might buck the local trend to use weatherboard and insulate the walls so that nothing can get in or out – he stands by the ‘breathing’ qualities of RE walls and questions the insulation sealed-box approach to homes, including concerns about humidity.
It’s this sense of connection to a natural, living breathing material and less artificial temperature control that attracts many of Geraets customers. With the new Healthy Homes Guarantee Bill at front of mind, he feels we now have an opportunity to look beyond insulation and heat pumps, to ask what a healthy home really is. So, what does he want to see happen in New Zealand?
“The main thing here is an acceptance that rammed earth is an intelligent method of construction and that it is realistically affordable here in New Zealand. Just think what you get for your buck: health, comfort, durability, low maintenance, low carbon footprint and of course a beautiful, original building.”