• Home
• Magazine
• Blog & Podcast
• Idealog TV
• Directory
• Celsias

• Business Magazine of the Year MPA Awards 2007, 2008 & 2009 Business Website of the Year MPA Awards 2009

The peasants are revolting

I’ve never seen Digg, the mondo community link-sharing site, quite as busy as it is right now. The Digg front page is full of stories that have been ‘dugg’ thousands of times, all of them including a short string of hexadecimal numbers that Digg has declared verboten.  Today, Digg's users are rebelling.

Digg's publishers must be wondering what the hell is going on. Digg's fanbase is usually fawning, but earlier today the site decided to delete stories that include a key that can be used to decrypt protected HD-DVD disks (this is apparently illegal in the US, where freedom of speech applies to people but perhaps not to software). That caused some unhappiness, but a user soon noticed that the HD-DVD Group sponsors a webcast produced by Digg’s founders and the revolt began. Digg users, who had bought in to the idea that Digg stories were entirely suggested and voted on by the user community, are not happy and they're making their displeasure known the only way most of them know how—on Digg, of course.

It's interesting to watch and, at the moment at least, Digg users seem to be able to post and vote on stories quicker than Digg management can remove them.

It's not that long ago that an earlier news aggregation site with a technical slant, Slashdot, seemed to have a near-untouchable user community but when Slashdot stagnated many users quickly jumped ship to the easier-to-use Digg. Is Digg now running the risk that it might lose a large chunk of its audience? The controversy is just sending more traffic to Digg at the moment, but this would be a really good time for Digg to show it shares the concerns of its customers.

[Update: it does. Digg founder Kevin Rose has joined the revolt.] 

Comments

Charlie

May 4, 2007 at 9:51 am

An interesting thing here is that Digg (the company) may very well have a real liability on their hands. So while the rebellion demonstrates the mobility of the community, it's possible that it will also damage the community...likely impact they implement tighter moderation to protect themselves, worst case scenario Digg gets sued out of existance (I doubt it).

The next Diggnation podcast sure will make for good listening.

Matt Cooney

May 4, 2007 at 12:48 pm

Thanks Charlie. It's certainly possible, although I kinda think Digg has been forced to make a decision to go with its users and not try to control them. But I don't doubt the risk they're running by flouting the DMCA ... perhaps they should move head office to Enzed where we don't have such stupid legislation. Yet, anyway.

I'm still amazed by what transpired at Digg yesterday and I'd love to think what other sites with user-generated content think about it (Amazon, YouTube, etc. Trade Me?) I'll have more to say about this in my weekly newsletter that comes out about ... now ...

Ben Kepes

May 4, 2007 at 4:29 pm

It's an intensly interesting situation. Take the power of community that is a feature of the modern community more so than ever before, add a situation where a business faces the choices of losing that communities buy-in or facing a legal/financial threat and watch the sparks fly. It could be said that DIGG, by first censoring, and then self publishing, the code, did a double disservice to itself. True they were between a rock and a hard place but they not only alienated their community but brought themselves under the threat of legal action - double whammy!

Add your comment

HTML will be removed. Web addresses will be automatically hyperlinked.

Anonymous comments are queued before publishing and may take some time to appear. Or you can create an account and your comment will bypass our bureaucracy.

Your comment Name Email (hidden) Website Security check

Tweeted

Overheard

• steer seo on Bigger, faster, more productive:
  It's got to be good for online retailers selling to the US. They will be able to offer a better multi-media experience.
• Mark on Bigger, faster, more productive:
  Fantastic! Finally some vision in establishing a key infrastructure to support New Zealand's future prosperity and commercial competitiveness. Good work Rod, Sam and Steve - your country thanks you for your patriotism!  …
• Margaret Holmes on NZ Institute thumbs down Key's agenda:
  Unfortunately it is not just red tape - it is also the laid back kiwi attitude, compounded by educators who think achieving national standards is a bad thing.
• Tim Marshall on Smile, you’re in New Zealistan:
  The target of higher GDP per capita is all wrong. Aiming for it encourages more production and consumption, often at the expense of quality of life. We need to construct a Genuine Progress Index (GPI) to guide policy. Fr  …
• Peter McL on New note:
  "You got caught up in events at EMI.." and yet shes STILL with EMI - their local branch is distributing her new album. Wonder why?
  
  I blogged some more of Hollies comments on the details behind the fallout  …
• Phil Wollerman on Smile, you’re in New Zealistan:
  Brilliant, insightful article, VH.
  
  This situation has principally arisen because - simplistically - the world no longer wants what we are intrinsically advantaged in supplying.
  
  And yeah, it doesn't look like our co  …

• Back to top
• Looking for something else? Check the site map
• © 2005–2010 Idealog. All rights reserved. ISSN 1179–3465